2016 Lindenwood 7-1-0 Carl Hutter                    
2015 Upper Iowa 6-2 Jason Carlson
2014 Northeastern State 11-0-1 Rob Czlonka    Tournament: Northeastern State
2013 Lindenwood 7-0-1 Carl Hutter                    Tournament: Lindenwood
2012 Lindenwood 8-0-2 Carl Hutter                    Tournament: Lindenwood

MIAA Titles won or shared: Lindenwood 3, Northeastern State 1, Upper Iowa 1